The Great College Waitlist Bidding War of 2025

⚠️ IMPORTANT SERVICE ANNOUNCEMENT ⚠️
We're moving away from Beehiiv due to ongoing delivery delays. To ensure you never miss time-sensitive admissions updates, please add [email protected] to your address book. All future newsletters will come directly from this address.

It's May 7th, 2025, and something strange is happening in college admissions.

Just yesterday, I spoke with three different families who received surprising calls from their waitlist schools. Not just with offers of admission – but with significant financial aid packages. Some better than what they got from their original schools.

"We assumed the waitlist was a longshot," one parent told me. "We definitely didn't expect them to offer $10,000 more per year than our committed school."

This isn't an isolated incident.

Across our network, we're seeing a fundamental shift in how colleges are handling their waitlists this year.

Let me explain what's happening – and why it matters for your family.

The Hidden Reality of Post-Deposit Day 2025

Colleges are facing a perfect storm:

• More students holding multiple deposits

• Increased summer melt concerns

• International enrollment uncertainties

• Department-specific gaps to fill

• Housing capacity issues

The result? Schools are getting aggressive – and creative – with their waitlist offers.

The Numbers You Need to Know

Here's what we're seeing across our network:

• 30-40% of waitlist offers now include additional aid

• Typical increases ranging from $5,000-$15,000 per year

• Most common offers falling in the $8,000-$12,000 range

• Some department-specific incentives

• Occasional housing guarantees as added leverage

But Here's The Critical Part

This isn't happening equally across all schools or programs.

The most active offers are coming from:

1. Private universities managing yield rates

2. Schools with specific departmental gaps

3. Institutions facing unexpected enrollment shifts

4. Universities competing for specific academic profiles

The New Timeline That Changes Everything

Forget everything you thought you knew about May 1st being the end of the process. Here's what's really happening:

May 1-15:

• Initial deposit numbers become clear

• Schools identify preliminary gaps

• First wave of waitlist outreach begins

• Early financial aid adjustments

May 15-31:

• Serious waitlist activity starts

• Initial competitive offers emerge

• Department-specific recruitment begins

• Housing assignments create new openings

June:

• Major waitlist movement

• Increased financial aid offers

• Students begin releasing deposits

• New spaces continue opening

July:

• Continued significant movement

• Some of the best financial offers appear

• Summer melt creates opportunities

• Department gaps become critical

August:

• Last major push for enrollment

• Often very competitive aid packages

• Housing reshuffling creates space

• Final department needs addressed

Early September:

• Final adjustments before census

• Last-minute opportunities

• Some surprising offers still appear

• Final week of meaningful movement

Real Examples From This Week

Case Study #1: Engineering Major

• Original aid package: $20,000/year

• Waitlist offer: $28,000/year

• Additional department grant: $4,000

• Result: $12,000 more annually

Case Study #2: Business Student

• Original merit award: $15,000/year

• Competing offer: $23,000/year

• Housing guarantee included

• Result: Leveraged for $8,000 more at original school

The New Strategic Framework

Given this shifting landscape, here's how to play it smart:

Step 1: Assess Your Current Position

• What's your current aid package?

• How firmly committed are you to your deposit school?

• What would make you consider switching?

• What's your ideal outcome?

Step 2: Calculate Your Leverage

Schools are most likely to make competitive offers if:

• You're in a high-demand major

• You have strong academic metrics

• You fill a demographic need

• You've shown genuine interest but not desperation

Step 3: Position Strategically

DO:

• Keep communication professional and metrics-focused

• Highlight any new achievements or projects

• Be clear about what would make you switch

• Understand each school's specific needs

DON'T:

• Commit to leaving your current school prematurely

• Show desperation or over-eagerness

• Accept the first offer without negotiation

• Burn bridges with your deposit school

Making The Decision: Your Action Plan

1. Document Everything

• Current aid package details

• New offers received

• All communication with schools

• Deadline requirements

2. Create Your Bottom Line

• Minimum aid needed to switch

• Non-negotiable requirements

• Deal-breaker factors

• Timeline limitations

3. Maintain Professional Communication

• Keep all schools informed

• Document conversations

• Maintain positive relationships

• Leave doors open

The Ethical Considerations

Yes, it's okay to:

• Consider multiple offers

• Negotiate aid packages

• Take time to decide

• Choose what's best for your family

No, you shouldn't:

• Make promises you won't keep

• Play schools against each other aggressively

• Mislead about intentions

• Delay decisions unnecessarily

Looking Forward

This new landscape presents both opportunities and challenges.

The key is understanding that:

• You have more leverage than you might think

• Schools are more flexible than in previous years

• The timeline is longer than most realize

• Professional communication remains essential

Important Context

While we're seeing increased flexibility in aid packages, keep expectations realistic:

• Most additional aid falls in the $5,000-$15,000 per year range

• Not every waitlist offer includes additional aid

• Offers vary significantly by institution and program

• Your student's specific profile matters enormously

Next Steps

If you're currently on a waitlist:

1. Review your current commitment

2. Assess your leverage points

3. Prepare your documentation

4. Monitor communication channels

5. Be ready to move quickly

Remember: This new environment rewards strategic patience and professional communication. The old rules of desperate appeals and weekly updates are dead. Instead, focus on understanding your value proposition and being ready to move when the right offer comes.

Important Newsletter Update

As mentioned above, we're transitioning away from Beehiiv to provide you with more reliable, timely delivery of critical admissions information. Here's what you need to do:

1. Add [email protected] to your address book

2. Check your spam folder and mark our emails as "not spam" if you find them there

3. If you use Gmail, move our emails from the "Promotions" tab to "Primary"

This ensures you'll receive time-sensitive updates about waitlists, aid packages, and admissions opportunities as soon as they're available.

Want to discuss your specific situation? Click here to schedule a strategy session.

Because in 2025, the waitlist isn't just about waiting anymore.

It's about understanding your value and leveraging it effectively.

Best,
Kristina

P.S. With this extended admissions season, you have more options than you might think. If you'd like to discuss your situation, don't wait. Click here to secure your spot.